Posted by: subo | April 5, 2008

should this book be required reading for pastoral work?

“Counselling in Context: Developing a Theological Framework”
by Francis Bridger & David Atkinson

Hi Folk, have just started reading Francis Bridger and David Atkinson’s book, a few months after completing a diploma in Person-Centred counselling, I’ve put off reading this critical book, as know they were going to have a pop at some of my hero’s, however, as a very serious and thoughtful book I had to have a look.

the authors are concerned about how church pastoral work has let go of the historical traditions, and taken up with ideas from 20th cent influences like Freud (dread the thought!), however, they look at details of contemporary writers in pastoral ministry, and I’m now enjoying reading this book.

It was a bit of a blow, having slogged away to train my counselling skills, to then read about the damage counselling can do, however you don’t need to spend long in counselling to see some of the ego trips counsellors slip into, and want to ask some questions.

has anyone else read this book?, or another in the same field?, I’m going to read ‘The Beautiful Risk: A New Psychology of Loving and Being Loved’ by James H. Olthuis, when I can get a copy.

am wondering if this post is a bit out of place on this blog, but know there’s a few philosophers and ministers writing on here occasionally, and I do think it’s an important aspect of church life to discuss, so very much hope to get some interesting comments.

Responses

Haven’t read them Su, but they sound really interesting. I think it is right to question some counselling practice. Undoubtedly much is very good- however I am sure there is some dodgy practice out there- especially by well meaning,people who have dabbled with a short course and then think they are fully trained! i mean this in contrast to your hard slog of gaining a diploma!.

I don’t know much about counselling (tried going to one once when I was younger and was bizarrely disappointed that she was not telepathic and that I actually had to talk about my problems in order for her to know what they were!!!!) But I wonder how much of the surrounding theory is useful to the patient (counsellee?), or the counsellor for that matter… Am I naive in thinking that really all people want when they go to a counsellor is someone to listen to them? Do they care whether that person signs up to a particular scheme of thought or not??

hi Sonia and Clare, thanks for comments, - I’m collecting ‘useless counsellor memories’, sadly there seems to be many!

fortunately the book gets more exciting in the second half, when they get on to their understanding of Christian counselling, will write up about it when I’ve read a bit more

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories